In March of this year, I reported on the newly introduced Bank of America Cooperative Short Sale Program. As noted in that post, the two key elements of this new program are the relocation fee of $2500 paid to the sellers, and the timeline. Instead of waiting for the short sale seller to find a buyer, this program was designed so that a seller could submit all paperwork in advance and be approved prior to a purchase offer. According to Bank of America, by approving the property value and seller hardship up front, this would decrease the amount of time needed to process the actual sale and approve the buyer once an offer is presented to the bank. At that time, the bank indicated this would shorten that approval timeframe to about 10 days.
So when my negotiator called last Friday to let me know that Bank of America had determined that one of my files might be eligible for a Cooperative Short Sale, my first thought was, “Great!” I figured that we’d be able to get this closed quickly as we already have a strong buyer, and my sellers would receive $2500 to help with moving costs.
I then asked about any down-side to my sellers accepting the Cooperative Short Sale versus a traditional B of A short sale, and my negotiator’s response was surprising. She said that in her experience, (and she has been a full-time short sale negotiator for several years), the Bank of America Cooperative Program takes about 6-8 weeks LONGER than their regular short sales. Longer??? The normal B of A processing time is 6-8 weeks, and now participation in this program would essentially double that? According to my negotiator, the reason it takes longer is because there is a more intense review of all seller financials – probably needed to justify the $2500 relocation payment.
My first thought as a Realtor protecting my seller’s interests, is that participating in this program could double the chances of a buyer to walk! It is hard enough to keep buyers waiting 6-8 weeks for an approval, but to extend that period for another 2 months is asking for trouble! I have also heard it rumored that by performing a more intense financial review B of A is actually looking to see who has sufficient assets to target with a deficiency judgment. I don’t have any evidence to support this, but it could pose a potential risk if there is any question as to whether or not the seller’s loan is protected under the state’s anti-deficiency laws.
I presented the choice to my sellers who quickly decided that the risk of losing their buyers was not worth a $2500 gamble. Who knows? Their file might have been processed quickly, but on the other hand we might have ended-up back at square one looking for a new buyer. It is definitely a choice that each seller will have to make based on their unique situation. If anyone out there has experience with this B of A program, I’d love to hear from you!
June 22, 2011 at 6:11 pm
I appreciate theses comments because I have been proposed to accept this new program as an alternative to a foreclosure and will appreciate more comments in order to make a wise decision.
June 22, 2011 at 11:06 pm
Hi Benjamin. Thank you for your response. I assume you are working with an experienced Realtor? If not, please let me know and I can help you find someone. If you are in southern California, I can help you. It sounds like you really need to consult about your particular situation. The short sale situation is very particular to each borrower and you should consult further.
August 24, 2011 at 10:10 am
I live in Southwest Florida and have been battling B of A for almost 3 years. I finally gave up and left my house for foreclosure last November. A representative of B of A called and offered me the Cooperative Short Sale program. I had already moved out and had nothing to lose so I said ok. I got a realtor friend to list the house and by the end of May had a closing date. The buyer had a probem with financing and walked. One week later, we had another contract from a pre-approved B of A borrower for an amount that was higher than the already bank approved sale price. I had to ‘reapply’ for the program with the new contract, and somehow got tied into the HAFA program. I sent all of the documents via fax a few times, as did my realtor, and now it is almost three months later and after being shuffled around to different departments and vendors, learned that I was kicked out of the program last month for ‘lack of documents’…which documents…nobody seems to know, but they do know that they don’t have them, and now I must reapply for a THIRD time to the Cooperative Short Sale program…which, by the way, doesn’t allow you to have a contract pending, and I’m told that I will be contacted in 7-10 business days to be informed which of the 1000 documents that I’ve already filled out and faxed at least 5 times each since November of last year, will have to be refaxed…and if my buyer is still around, he can sign another contract after the bank re-appraises my home…and then wait another two months for the bank to re-approve the loan and sell the house. Whatever. I’m convinced that the bank DOES NOTwant to sell my house…but what they DO want is for me to call them a few thousand more times and fax a couple hundred more of the same documents. Along with my realtor….B of A…take my house and shove it up your ass….I have no assets…so have fun suing me.
August 26, 2011 at 12:13 pm
Whoa! I am sooo sorry to hear about your mess with B of A…..but not surprised. I am convinced that the fax machines at most of the banks empty directly into the trash. There is simply no other explanation for so many documents disappearing into the black hole. Please keep us updated, and good luck!
April 25, 2012 at 2:56 pm
BOA SUCKS BIGTIME!!! I WENT THROUGH THE EXACT SAME PROCESS AS GENTLEMAN FROM ABOVE, BUT NOT TO SELL THE HOME, BUT RATHER APPLYING FOR A LOAN MOD. WHICH PROBABLY WILL NEVER EVER EVER HAPPEN. BOA GET REAL!!!
I JUST GOT A CALL FROM A LADY FROM BOA THAT WANTS ME TO DO A COOPERATIVE SHORT SALE, PROBABLY JUST ANOTHER NIGHTMARE THEY WANT ME TO GO THROUGH, NO THANKS!!! I AGREE WITH GUY ABOVE THAT SAYS WHERE BOA SHOULD STICK OUR HOMES. NOT KIDDING HERE, THEY SUCK BIGTIME.